Facebook is not the Holy Grail

Today I've been reading Rex Hammock's Weblog (thanks Voidstar for the link) who writes about how Facebook it's not really the Holy Grail for either social networking or being the ultimate tool for collaborative working and tracking. He calls it' "geek play", and I agree. He says:

Facebook is not even close to being what will ultimately be that thing which alters fundamentally the way in which we relate and communicate. It may show us the way, but there are some important factors related to personal identity and social interaction that Facebook — or any platform that requires us to create community that is locked inside a wall — will not be able to overcome if it is to become the next be-all, end-all.

He also mentioned Ning which was previewed last year at Content 2.0 here in London when Marc Canter got up on stage and pointed out that MySpace users couldn't own theor own profiles or move them around networks. Well guess what? here we are again with the same old issue all over again, this time with Facebook.

Meanwhile over here, "A VC in NYC" agrees with Jason Calacanis that "Facebook Bakruptcy" is where you have total overload of friend requests and incoming stuff to deal with. Plus FB is becoming so successful, startups are wondering if they should just build an application for Facebook rather than build out a whole web service.

My view is that building a site is a marathon not a sprint. If you can't control your content then you have no business long term. Sure, market your site on Facebook - but don't for pete's sake put your whole idea into it.

Trackback URL for this post:

http://www.mbites.com/trackback/691

Mike - way too many people

Mike - way too many people are blinkered on this. None of these discussions address the business aspect. By that I mean business user. Business spends $1 trillion a year on IT 'stuff' - way above consumer. 99% of Google's revenue comes from business and it is a minnow in the scale of things. Facebook is right for THAT community. Check this for the ups and downs: http://blogs.zdnet.com/Howlett/?p=112

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
More information about formatting options